Contemplation Upon Dukkha or Suffering
Summary: Dukkha, or suffering, is the first of the Four Noble Truths in Buddhism. This essay provides an in-depth exploration of the nature of dukkha from the Buddhist perspective — its meaning, its various forms, and how practicing contemplation upon suffering can cultivate equanimity, detachment, and ultimately the wisdom needed to end it.
In its extreme interpretation, which is often necessary to understand the Four Noble Truths of Buddhism and the imperative urgency of practicing the Eightfold Path, Dukkha shold be understood not as mere physical pain, sorrow, or suffering. It includes every disturbance, distraction, or modification that arises within the mind and body or happens to the mind and body and their aggregates due to internal or external causes.
Some scholars translated the word as stress, but 'stress' does not adequately convey its spiritual or philosophical meaning or scope.
Technically, everything that we know or interact with can potentially produce suffering and every aspect of our fragile minds and bodies are vulnerable to it.
The aggregates of the mind and body are predisposed to produce Dukkha because they are subject to change, impermanence, aging, sickness, and death. They are also impure, since they are subject to karma, ignorance, egoism, anger, pride, envy, and other effluents.
Beings are subject to birth, death, rebirth, decay aging, sickness, attraction and aversion, separation and union with pleasant and unpleasant things, and so on. They are but different formations of Dukkha only. Therefore, know that Dukkha is an inescapable fact of life.
You are caught in the whirl of Dukkha. You are its subject and object, cause and effect. You are empty within yourself, but for now that emptiness is filled with the aggregates of Dukkha namely the body, feelings, perception, mental fabrications and consciousness. They are but the different aggregations of Dukkha only, created by karma.
No one can escape from Dukkha as long as karma is active and continuous. Therefore, like a shadow, from one birth to another, suffering follows everyone.
Fortunately, as everything else in the phenomenal world, Dukkha is also impermanent. By mindfully watching its coming and going or rising and falling in your mind and body, you can gain a direct experience of impermanence.
Impermanence of things also means that you can find moments of peace and respite in the continuous stream of Dukkha. It also means that you can hope for improvement or mitigation of your suffering through the practice of Dharma.
However, do not expect lasting happiness to arise from your mind and body. The five impure and imperfect aggregates are ill-equipped to produce perfect happiness. The happiness which arises from them or in them is always tainted with impermanence, fluctuations and instability.
Apart from thinking of impermanence, you can counter Dukkha by focusing upon emptiness also. By emptiness (shunya) we mean that phenomenal things are empty in themselves. They do not possess an indestructible essence, which outlasts them or pervades them.
Your Dukkha is also an empty formation. It can be dispelled or dissolved into nothingness. Therefore, when Dukkha arises, know that it is empty in itself, and if you let it be, it will collapse soon into emptiness.
Dukkha is an objective reality or the not-self reality. It arises and subsides within the not-self only. The notion that it happens to an eternal self or a permanent subject is an illusion. If Hinduism emphasizes Death as the Supreme Lord and an inescapable fact of life, Buddhism recognizes Dukkha, besides Death, as the harsh reality of our existence, from which one must seek release or remain bound to samsara.
The one who experiences Dukkha is also a formation who comes into existence through the aggregates of the mind and body. It is empty in itself and devoid of essence. Therefore, cultivate detachment and become a witness to your suffering with sameness, rather than becoming a victim of it.
When Dukkha arises, remember that it is happening in you, not to you. Let that suffering become diffused, just as a wave that rises and falls on its own in an ocean. Do not assume ownership or relationship, for it can set in motion a chain of karma and further suffering.
Dukkha is an inseparable and inescapable fact of life. You are made up of Dukkha, and live amidst Dukkha. You create Dukkha and suffer from Dukkha.
Dukkha cannot be mitigated by producing happiness because your mind and body are ill equipped to produce lasting happiness or pure happiness.
Enjoy happy moments when they arise, but know that they will soon be gone and replaced by other feelings and emotions.
When Dukkha arises in any form, pay attention to it. See with mindfulness its coming and going or rising and falling. Practice equanimity, with detachment, sameness and forbearance. With the insight and wisdom (prajna) thus gained, cultivate right views, right intentions and right resolve to attain nirvana on the Eightfold Path.